One of the questions I regularly get asked by GDPs is whether they should treat a patient with Invisalign or fixed appliances. It’s a reasonable question, particularly when you’re starting to provide orthodontic treatment.
However, before choosing an appliance, you need to establish whether the case is suitable for you to treat and exactly what tooth movements you’re trying to achieve. Once you know that, the choice of appliance usually becomes much clearer.
What each appliance does well
Fixed appliances generally give us greater flexibility when it comes to controlling tooth movements. We can adjust our mechanics during treatment, introduce additional auxiliaries and respond when teeth aren’t moving as expected. This is particularly useful in cases involving significant rotations, root torque or space closure.
Aligners can also achieve many of these movements, but their predictability varies. Attachments, staging, auxiliaries and patient compliance all make a difference. Just because a movement looks achievable on ClinCheck doesn’t necessarily mean it will happen clinically.
I don’t think one appliance is better than the other overall. For mild to moderate cases, both can give a good result. For more complex movements, I find fixed appliances give me more control and more predictable results.
Case selection
When assessing a case, I would encourage GDPs to think about the individual tooth movements required rather than just the severity of crowding.
For example, a patient with relatively mild crowding may appear to be an ideal aligner case. However, if the treatment requires difficult premolar rotations, significant root movement or substantial changes in the vertical dimension, it may prove more challenging than expected.
Equally, a patient with moderate crowding and favourable tooth movements may be perfectly suitable for aligner treatment. The key is understanding the biomechanics before committing to an appliance.
Cases that tend to do well with aligners:
- Mild to moderate crowding or spacing
- Some bite corrections, where there aren’t significant vertical or rotational demands
- Patients who will genuinely wear their aligners. In my experience, compliance makes a bigger difference to aligner outcomes than almost anything else.
Cases where I’d still lean towards fixed appliances:
- Significant rotations, particularly on rounded teeth such as canines and premolars. Aligners can struggle to fully correct these without attachments and careful staging.
- Cases needing significant root torque or bodily movement
- Complex bite corrections or cases with a skeletal element
- Patients you’re not confident will wear their aligners consistently
- Extraction cases
This isn’t a list of cases GDPs should avoid. Many of them are perfectly manageable with the right training. They’re simply cases where fixed appliances are usually the more appropriate choice.
Where GDPs get caught out
One of the problems I see when reviewing cases is that the proposed treatment plan looks excellent on the computer, but the clinician hasn’t fully considered whether the planned movements are achievable.
With aligners, this can result in teeth failing to track, incomplete rotations or insufficient torque expression. Often, the first instinct is to order a refinement, but unless we understand why the movement hasn’t occurred, we may simply repeat the same problem.
This is why I place so much emphasis on reviewing the treatment plan before starting, rather than trying to correct problems halfway through treatment.
Being able to spot these problems early mostly comes from experience. You need to have seen enough cases, including the ones that didn’t go to plan. When you’re starting out, having someone check your ClinCheck or wire sequence before you begin can save you a lot of difficulty later on.
Final thoughts
Both aligners and fixed appliances have an important place in orthodontic treatment. I use both, and the choice depends on the patient’s malocclusion, the treatment objectives and the movements required.
For GDPs starting out in orthodontics, my advice is to keep your case selection sensible and avoid taking on cases where you cannot confidently explain how you’re going to achieve the desired result.
This is one of the main reasons I set up the Online Orthodontic Academy: to give GDPs access to specialist advice when planning and treating cases, rather than having to work everything out themselves. You can read what other GDPs have said about the mentoring in our testimonials.
If you’d like to find out more, you can start with the free 5-day taster, or book a free mentorship call with me to talk through how case selection is covered in the mentoring.

Copyright Online Orthodontic Academy | Design & Build Cityspace Creative
